On a remote island in Maine, a group of friends thought they witnessed one man killing another with an ax. But no one was ever arrested. In a small town far out at sea, justice sometimes works a little differently.

A shoot-out at a Big Bend ranch captured the nation’s attention: first as an alleged ambush by undocumented migrants, then as a fear-mongering hoax. The real story is much more mysterious.

ShyShy Pate has been missing for 19 years, but you’ve probably never heard of her.

Who killed four people in the French Alps?

A group of teens allegedly create a violent game with a simple premise: “to knock out a stranger with a single punch.”