A 55-year-old cold case ends with a conviction. But was justice really served?

  1. A Child Vanishes

    Playing outside after dinner, best friends Kathy and Maria meet a man calling himself “Johnny.” Kathy runs home to grab mittens; upon her return, her 7-year-old friend and the stranger are nowhere to be found.

  2. Women Wronged

    The story of Jack McCullough, once known as John Tessier, a man who once lived near Kathy and Maria and has a troubling history of abusing women.

  3. Bulldogs on the Case

    Police zero in on McCullough after a deathbed confession.

  4. 'That's Him'

    Half a century after her friend was abducted, Kathy identifies the man who took Maria.

  5. The Whole Truth?

    Jack McCullough is convicted of Maria’s kidnapping and murder, but questions are raised about the evidence (or lack thereof) presented at trial.